Golden-crust pizza fresh from the oven at Nostalgia Pizza Shop
Zephyrhills, Florida

A Slice of the Good Old Days

Hand-tossed, golden-crust pizzas made with care in Zephyrhills - voted one of the best pizza spots in town.

Our Story

Made With Care, Served With Heart

Nostalgia Pizza Shop is a family-run corner of Zephyrhills where every pie carries the warmth of the good old days. We hand-toss each crust, ladle on rich tomato sauce, and pile on melted mozzarella the way pizza was always meant to be. From our meaty Loaded pie to the garden-fresh Supreme, everything comes out hot, generous, and made to order - a comforting slice worth coming back for.

Loaded pizza topped with bacon, beef, sausage, and pepperoni
Fresh From the Oven

Fresh From the Oven

Golden crusts, generous toppings, and that just-baked aroma - here are the pies our neighbors keep ordering.

16"Extra Large 16 inch cheese pizza with golden crust

Extra Large 16”

A 16-inch pizza with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a thick, golden crust.

14"Large 14 inch cheese pizza with melted mozzarella

Large 14"

A 14-inch pizza with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a thick, golden crust.

Loaded pizza with bacon, beef, sausage, and pepperoni

Loaded

Bacon, beef, sausage, and pepperoni team up for a meaty extravaganza!

10"Small 10 inch cheese pizza with golden crust

Small 10"

A 10-inch pizza with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a thick, golden crust.

12"Medium 12 inch cheese pizza with rich tomato sauce

Medium 12"

A 12-inch pizza with a generous layer of melted mozzarella cheese and a rich tomato sauce on a thick, golden crust.

Supreme pizza loaded with pepperoni, sausage, peppers, onions, and mushrooms

Supreme

A pizza paradise loaded with pepperoni, sausage, red peppers, green peppers, red onions, and mushrooms, crowned with a cheesy mozzarella extravaganza. Dive into layers of deliciousness with every slice!

Word Around Town

Word Around Town

4.3 average rating from 193 reviews

The food was beyond delicious...fresh, flavorful, and made perfectly. Every bite tasted like it was made with care. The pizza crust was just right, the toppings were generous, and everything came out hot and delicious. Definitely one of the best pizza spots in Zephyrhills, and I can’t wait to order again!

Jessica H

Delicious as always!! Best pizza in town!! Love this shop and will absolutely order again. Have had delivered and stopped in and had a slice for lunch a couple times and is always great! Large 14" is good and has good size slices. Is always fresh and warm.

Christopher H
Find Us

Visit Us

Where to Find Us

38426 5th Ave
Zephyrhills, FL 33542
United States

(813) 355-4076
Delivery Pickup

When We're Slinging Slices

Sunday
Closed
Monday
Closed
Tuesday
12:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Wednesday
12:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Thursday
12:00 PM - 8:00 PM
Friday
12:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Saturday
12:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Order Online
Good to Know

Good to Know

What meals do you serve?
Nostalgia Pizza Shop in Zephyrhills, FL serves authentic Italian-style pizzas perfect for family dinners, casual lunches, and pizza nights. We offer a variety of sizes, including a Small 10", Medium 12", Large 14", and Extra Large 16", each featuring a thick golden crust, rich tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese. Our signature Loaded pizza combines bacon, beef, sausage, and pepperoni for a hearty, meaty experience. Whether you're feeding one or a crowd, Nostalgia Pizza Shop has the perfect pie for every occasion.
Do you offer delivery or takeout?
Yes, we offer both delivery and pickup. Order your favorite pizza with ease today!
Where are you located?
Nostalgia Pizza Shop is located at 38426 5th Ave, Zephyrhills, FL 33542, United States.
What areas do you serve?
We proudly serve Zephyrhills and surrounding areas including Wesley Chapel, Dade City, Land O' Lakes, New Tampa, Lutz, San Antonio, Crystal Springs, Pasco, Trilby, and Richland, FL.
This site uses our own and third-party cookies and similar technologies to ensure our site and services function, personalize user experiences, analyze and improve website performance and content, and for advertising purposes. For more information please review our Cookie Policy. Click “Essential only” to reject non-essential cookies, or “Close” to continue without changing your preferences. Manage cookie preferences here